Solar vs Generator: Best Power Options for Homesteads
Choosing between solar power and generators for your homestead? Here’s what you need to know:
| Feature | Solar Power | Generators |
|---|---|---|
| Energy Source | Sunlight | Fossil fuels |
| Initial Cost | $10,000 – $30,000 | $200 – $20,000 |
| Long-term Savings | High | Low |
| Environmental Impact | Minimal | Higher (emissions) |
| Reliability | Weather-dependent | Fuel-dependent |
| Maintenance | Low | Regular |
Key Takeaways:
- Solar is best for long-term savings and eco-friendliness
- Generators offer reliable, immediate power regardless of weather
- Many homesteaders use both for a balanced approach
Quick Comparison:
| Aspect | Solar Power | Generators |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront Cost | Higher | Lower |
| Ongoing Costs | Very low | Fuel and maintenance |
| Power Output | Variable | Consistent |
| Noise Level | Silent | Loud (70-80 dB) |
| Lifespan | 25-35 years | 4-6 years |
| Best For | Long-term savings, eco-conscious | Immediate power, backup |
Your best choice depends on your location, budget, and power needs. Many homesteaders find a combination of both systems works best, providing reliability and efficiency.
How Much Power Does Your Homestead Need?
Figuring out your homestead’s power needs is tricky. Too little, and you’re in the dark. Too much, and you’re wasting money. Let’s break it down:
Basic Power Needs
Most homesteads need juice for:
- Lights
- Heating and cooling
- Keeping food cold
- Pumping water
- Running small appliances and gadgets
But here’s the thing: your actual usage can be all over the map. It depends on how you live and where you’re at. Check out these real-world numbers:
| Setup | Wattage | What You Can Run |
|---|---|---|
| Bare Bones | 1,000 – 1,500W | LED lights, laptop, phone charger, mini-fridge |
| Average Joe | 3,000 – 5,000W | Regular fridge, washer, fans, some electronics |
| Power Hungry | 8,000W+ | AC, dishwasher, electric water heater |
Crunching the Numbers
Want to figure out your power needs? Here’s how:
- List your stuff and how much power it uses
- Guess how long you use each thing daily
- Multiply power by hours used
- Add it all up
Let’s see it in action:
| Gadget | Power | Daily Use | Daily Power Used |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fridge | 150W | 24 hrs | 3,600 Wh |
| LED Lights (10) | 100W total | 5 hrs | 500 Wh |
| Laptop | 50W | 4 hrs | 200 Wh |
| Total | 4,300 Wh |
In this case, you’d need about 4.3 kWh per day.
“It’s not just something that you buy and just put away for an emergency this is something that you could roll in and incorporate to your daily use!” – Host of Wranglestar YouTube
Everyday vs. “Just in Case” Power
Here’s where it gets interesting. Your daily needs are one thing, but what about when stuff hits the fan?
Everyday Power: This is what you use, well, every day. Most homesteads use between 10 and 30 kWh daily.
“Just in Case” Power: This is your backup plan. Think blackouts, emergencies, or cloudy days if you’re using solar. A good rule? Plan for 3-7 days of backup.
Here’s what that looks like:
| Power Type | How to Figure It Out | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Everyday | Average daily use | 15 kWh/day |
| “Just in Case” (3 days) | Daily use x 3 | 45 kWh |
Keep in mind, these are just starting points. Your actual needs might be different. The key? Track what you use over time and adjust as you go.
“You can set this up so that you could be utilizing this producing power from your solar panels and doing using free Power and using it during those high peak times” – Host of Wranglestar YouTube
How Solar Power Works
Solar power systems are gaining traction among homesteaders. Let’s break down how they work and what you should know before making the switch.
Parts and Installation
A typical solar power system for a homestead includes:
- Solar panels
- Inverter
- Battery bank
- Charge controller
- Mounting equipment
- Wiring and cables
Each component plays a role. Solar panels convert sunlight into electricity. The inverter changes DC power to AC power for home use. Batteries store extra energy, while the charge controller manages power flow to them.
Most homesteaders opt for professional installation. It’s safer and ensures the system performs at its best.
Starting Costs
Solar power systems aren’t cheap, but prices have dropped. Here’s a rough breakdown:
| System Type | Cost Range |
|---|---|
| DC solar system | $6,000 – $10,000 |
| Mixed DC and AC system | $10,000 – $50,000 |
| AC solar system | $30,000 – $60,000 |
| AC system with backup generator | $40,000 – $70,000 |
Remember, these are ballpark figures. Your actual costs will vary based on system size, location, and equipment choices.
How Much Power You’ll Get
Your solar system’s output depends on several factors:
- Panel efficiency
- Available sunlight in your area
- System size
- Time of year
A 5kW system in a sunny spot might produce 20-25 kWh per day in peak summer. But don’t expect that year-round. Weather and seasons play a big role.
“Not only has the ability to power your house in an emergency but you can take it out with you you can use it in your Overland you can use it in your camper it’s a silent solution that will recharge itself from solar” – Host of Wranglestar YouTube
Battery Options
For off-grid systems, batteries are a must. They store extra energy for cloudy days or nighttime use. Here are some popular choices:
| Battery Type | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Lithium-ion | Efficient, long-lasting | Pricey upfront |
| LiFePO4 | Very safe, long cycle life | Higher initial cost |
| Lead-acid | Affordable, easy to find | Shorter lifespan, needs maintenance |
Most homesteaders go for lithium-ion or LiFePO4. They cost more upfront but perform better and last longer.
Upkeep and Care
Solar systems don’t need much maintenance, but some care helps:
- Clean panels now and then
- Check for damage or loose connections
- Keep an eye on system performance
- Trim nearby trees to avoid shade
- Replace the inverter every 10-15 years
Take care of your system, and it’ll take care of you. Modern solar panels can last 40-50 years, and many come with 25-year warranties.
How Generators Work
Generators are the backbone of off-grid power. They keep your homestead running when you need electricity most. Let’s break down how these machines work and why they’re so important.
Generator Options
You’ve got a few choices when it comes to powering your homestead:
| Generator Type | What It’s Good For | Upsides | Downsides |
|---|---|---|---|
| Home Standby | Powering your whole house | Turns on automatically, lots of power | Pricey, can’t move it |
| Portable | Using now and then, moving around | Cheap, flexible | Less power, you have to start it |
| Inverter | Powering delicate electronics | Clean power, sips fuel | Costs more, less power |
Home standby generators are the big guns. They can power your entire homestead. But they’re not cheap – you’re looking at $10,000 to $20,000 to get one installed.
Portable generators are like the Swiss Army knives of power. They’re great for occasional use and you can move them around. A good 5,000-watt model will cost you between $500 and $2,000.
Inverter generators are the new kids on the block. They make clean, stable power that won’t fry your fancy gadgets. The Bluetti Portable Power station is a good example – it can handle loads up to 1800W.
Fuel Types and Supply
Your generator needs food to run. Here’s what you need to know about different fuel types:
| Fuel Type | Good Stuff | Not So Good Stuff | How to Store It |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gasoline | Easy to find, cheap | Goes bad fast, can catch fire | Use a stabilizer, use it up |
| Propane | Burns clean, lasts a long time | Less energy dense | Keep in special tanks |
| Diesel | Efficient, runs for a long time | Costs more upfront | Keep it clean, use additives |
| Natural Gas | Always available, convenient | Needs a gas line, hard to move | Comes from the utility company |
For gas and diesel, always store fuel in airtight, OSHA-approved containers. Keep propane tanks outside where there’s good airflow.
“Not only has the ability to power your house in an emergency but you can take it out with you you can use it in your Overland you can use it in your camper it’s a silent solution.” – Host of Wranglestar YouTube
Monthly Costs
Running a generator isn’t free. Here’s what you might pay:
| Generator Size | Fuel Type | How Much Fuel Per Hour | Cost for 24 Hours |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 kW | Gasoline | 0.75 gallons | $52 |
| 20 kW | Diesel | 1.6 gallons | $122 |
| 20 kW | Propane | 3.45 gallons | $200+ |
| 7 kW | Natural Gas | 118 cubic feet | $20 |
These numbers are based on average fuel prices in 2023. Your costs might be different depending on local prices and how efficient your generator is.
Power Output Options
Picking the right size generator is key. Here’s a quick guide:
| Generator Size | What It Can Run |
|---|---|
| 2,000 – 4,000W | Basic stuff (lights, fridge, a few small appliances) |
| 5,000 – 7,500W | Most household needs (well pump, heating system) |
| 10,000W+ | Everything in your house, including AC and big appliances |
For most homesteads, a 5,000 to 10,000-watt generator hits the sweet spot. It’ll keep your essentials running without costing a fortune.
Regular Care Tasks
Take care of your generator, and it’ll take care of you. Here’s what you need to do:
1. Check the oil every month
Add or change oil as needed.
2. Look at the fuel system
Check for leaks or rust.
3. Clean or replace the air filter
Do this every 100 hours of use.
4. Test the battery
Make sure it’s charged and the connections are clean.
5. Run the generator monthly
Let it run for 20-30 minutes to keep everything lubricated.
“Now that we have starlink that technology in combination with an off-grid power system like this you’re not tethered you’re not Tethered to the power grid you can conduct your business.” – Host of Wranglestar YouTube
sbb-itb-7571093
Solar vs Generators: Side-by-Side
Let’s compare solar power and generators for homesteaders. This breakdown will help you pick the best option for your off-grid setup.
Setup Steps
Setting up solar power takes more time and often needs professional help. Generators are quicker to get running.
For solar:
- Install panels
- Set up inverter and batteries
- Connect to your home’s electrical system
- Configure the charge controller
For generators:
- Pick a spot
- Install a transfer switch
- Connect to fuel
- Set up ventilation
The EcoFlow DELTA Portable Power Station offers an easier solar setup. For generators, a Generac 10kW home generator might take a day or two to setup, while a portable Westinghouse Outdoor Portable can be ready in hours.
Long-term Costs
Solar wins for long-term savings. After the initial cost, you’ll spend very little. Most homesteads save about $1,500 a year on fuel compared to diesel generators.
Generators need ongoing fuel and upkeep. A 20kW diesel generator running for 24 hours could cost $122 in fuel alone.
| Expense | Solar Power | Generators |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel | Free (sunlight) | Ongoing (varies) |
| Maintenance | Minimal | Regular (oil, parts) |
| Lifespan | 25+ years | 10,000-30,000 hours |
| Replacement | Inverter every 10-15 years | Whole unit after lifespan |
How Well They Work
Solar panels turn about 15-20% of sunlight into electricity. A 5kW system in a sunny spot might make 20-25 kWh per day in summer.
Generators give steady power right away. A 20kW generator can handle most home needs, even when it’s cloudy.
| Factor | Solar Power | Generators |
|---|---|---|
| Weather dependence | High | Low |
| Power output | Changes | Steady |
| Night use | Needs batteries | Always ready |
| Scaling up | Easy | Limited by size |
Impact on Nature
Solar is the eco-friendly choice. It makes no emissions while working and has a smaller carbon footprint overall.
Generators have some environmental downsides. A typical portable gas generator puts out about 0.97 pounds of CO2 per kilowatt-hour – like a small car.
| Aspect | Solar Power | Generators |
|---|---|---|
| Emissions | None while working | CO2 and other pollution |
| Noise | Very little | Loud (70-80 dB) |
| Fuel storage risks | None | Possible spills |
Noise and Ease of Use
Solar systems are quiet and often run themselves. Many new systems, like the Tesla Powerwall 3, have smart features for easy monitoring.
Generators are noisier but simple to use. The Westinghouse WGen9500 has an electric start, but you’ll still need to add fuel and do regular maintenance.
| Feature | Solar Power | Generators |
|---|---|---|
| Noise | < 60 dB (very quiet) | 70-80 dB (loud) |
| Daily use | Automatic | Manual start/refueling |
| Monitoring | Often smart tech | Usually manual checks |
“Has plenty of power to run my furnace, living room outlets, kitchen outlets and upstairs bathroom and sump pump (the transfer switch kit has 6 circuits). Started first time using propane (my preferred fuel). Noise level is what one should expect from a portable generator” -K.McCrum Amazon reviewer
Using Both Systems Together
Combining solar power and generators gives you the best of both worlds. Here’s how to integrate these power sources for a reliable off-grid setup:
Setting Up Both Systems
To connect solar panels and generators, you’ll need:
- A hybrid inverter: This manages power from both sources.
- An automatic transfer switch: Switches between power sources without interruption.
- A properly sized generator: Choose one that handles peak loads at 75% capacity max.
Best Setup Methods
To maximize your dual power system:
- Use solar as your main source, generator as backup.
- Use smart power management apps to monitor and adjust energy use.
- Plan for growth. Some systems, can expand from 3,072Wh to 12,288Wh.
Is It Worth the Money?
Combining solar and generator power costs more upfront but offers:
| Benefit | Description |
|---|---|
| Reliability | Power during outages or bad weather |
| Flexibility | Adapts to changing energy needs |
| Cost savings | Less fuel costs long-term |
| Environmental impact | Smaller carbon footprint |
Hybrid solar systems average $32,000, while off-grid setups range from $50,000 to $65,000. Many find it worth it for energy independence.
Weather and Season Effects
Seasons impact power production:
| Season | Solar Production | Generator Usage |
|---|---|---|
| Summer | High | Low |
| Winter | Low | High |
| Spring/Fall | Moderate | Moderate |
In winter, when solar output drops, your generator becomes key. It can power high-wattage tools when solar can’t keep up.
“Thats way better than most gas generators that runs on 5 gallons of gas. And now I don’t need to keep all those gas cans laying around” Slvbult, Amazon reviewer on the BLUETTI Portable Power Station
Choosing Your Power System
Picking the right power setup for your homestead is a big deal. Let’s break it down:
Your Land and Location
Your property’s features can make or break your power choices:
| Factor | Solar Power | Generators |
|---|---|---|
| Sunlight | Needs lots of direct sun | Works in any weather |
| Tree cover | Can hurt efficiency | No problem |
| Fuel access | Not needed | Must be reliable |
| Local rules | May have limits | Noise/emissions rules |
Think about it: A sunny Arizona homestead? Solar might be perfect. But a wooded, rainy spot in Washington? Generators could be the way to go.
Money Matters
Let’s talk cash:
| System Type | Upfront Cost | Long-term Savings |
|---|---|---|
| Solar (5kW) | $15,000 – $20,000 | High |
| Backup Generator | $2,000 – $20,000 | Low |
| Off-grid Solar | $45,000 – $65,000 | Very High |
Keep in mind: These are just averages. Your actual costs? They’ll depend on what you need and where you live.
Here’s a pro tip: Look into tax breaks and incentives. Many states offer rebates for solar. It could seriously cut your upfront costs.
Long-term Results
Think about the future:
Solar? Low maintenance, quiet, and you might even sell extra power back to the grid.
Generators? Reliable power when you need it, but you’ll keep paying for fuel and upkeep.
Here’s a real-world example:
The Smith family in rural Texas put in a 10kW solar system with battery backup. Cost? $30,000 in 2020. After tax credits, they paid $22,200. Now they save about $2,400 a year on electricity. Plus, they have power when the grid goes down.
Growing Your System
Plan for the future:
1. Start small, think big
Begin with what you really need, but choose a system you can easily add to later.
2. Mix and match
Think about combining solar and generators. It gives you more options.
3. Battery power
If you go solar, invest in good batteries. You can add more over time.
“Uselton paid $25,000 upfront for his system. This year, it earned him a one-time $7,000 tax credit” – Dutch Uselton (source)
Finding the Solar Connection
Solar power or generators for your homestead? It’s not a simple choice. Both have their pros and cons. Your best pick depends on your situation, where you live, and what you can spend.
Let’s break it down:
| Factor | Solar Power | Generators |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront Cost | $15,000 – $20,000 (5kW) | $2,000 – $20,000 |
| Future Savings | Big | Small |
| Upkeep | Not much | Regular |
| How Long It Lasts | 25-35 years | 4-6 years |
| Earth-Friendly | Very | Not so much |
| Noise | None | Loud (70-80 dB) |
| Fuel Costs | Zero | Ongoing |
Solar’s a winner for saving money long-term and being kind to the planet. Dutch Uselton, a rural farmer, says it straight: “[our] co-op paid $2.50/watt. The average cost for residential solar panels in Texas is $4/watt.” It’s perfect if you’ve got plenty of sun and don’t need tons of power.
Generators? They’re reliable and cheaper to start. Great for backup or if you need power fast. But don’t forget about buying fuel and keeping them running.
Many homesteaders go for both. A mix of solar and generators gives you reliable power while saving cash and being more self-sufficient.
Keep in mind: your power needs might grow. Start with something you can add to later, like the BLUETTI AC180. You can always expand later.
Whatever you pick, focus on using less energy first. That’s the smart way to start your off-grid journey.
